Pakistan quake victims burn tyres at angry protests
MASHKAIL, Pakistan — Pakistani earthquake victims burnt tyres at angry protests on Friday, accusing the government of failing to provide adequate relief three days after their homes were destroyed or damaged. Tuesday’s 7.8-magnitude quake, centred in southeastern Iran, killed 41 people — all but one of whom were in Pakistan, where thousands more have been affected.
One of the worst-hit areas is Mashkail, a remote community in Pakistan’s southwestern province Baluchistan, where the lack of paved roads, phone coverage, immense distances and medical facilities have hampered the rescue effort. Several hundred protesters chanted slogans against the federal and provincial governments, set fire to tyres and blocked the road to vent their resentment in Mashkail, an AFP reporter said.
They demanded shelter and the restoration of electricity after poles in some areas were destroyed by the earthquake. “No one has received any relief item. The FC (Frontier Corps paramilitary) have distributed 20 tents which they gave only to influential people,” protester Ali Ahmad told AFP. Others said that children were sick. “Our children are having diarrhoea. When we took them to the health facility there is a shortage of medicine,” said another man.
Homeless families are camping out under date trees without tents or plastic sheets, although food and water is available in shops that remain open, coming from across the border with Iran. “If this earthquake had struck some other area, all the government machinery would have gone. Here only two government officials came but delivered nothing,” Mohammd Khalil, a driver, told AFP. “If they cannot do it, they should allow Iran to help us,” he added.
Violent protests in Moz gas, mining sectors forecast to surge in coming months
Mining and gas projects in Mozambique are likely to be affected by an increase in violent protests in the coming months, as local residents attempt to extract additional compensation from mining companies, especially in regions where projects are entering the construction phase, says political risk forecaster Exclusive Analysis, which was recently acquired by global advisory firm IHS.
Deputy head of Africa forecasting Robert Besseling tells Mining Weekly that, in recent months, there has been an increase in violent incidents at mining development sites in Tete province, in the north-west of Mozambique. Most of these incidents have to do with forced relocations and the lack of skills development in mining-prevalent regions.
As a result, protestors demanding greater benefits from the mining sector have been targeting mining sites and railway lines across the country. Late last month, local reports voiced the dis- content among Tete community members, who had been forcibly relocated to make way for coal mining operations and were dissatisfied with the compensation they received. This echoes the protests of Moatize local residents in January 2012, who blockaded the Sena public railway to prevent the transportation of coal from Tete to the Beira port.
Besseling likens the unrest brewing in Mozambique to discontent in the Tanzanian natural gas sector, which has also been experi- encing violent protests, motivated by discontent at relocations and a lack of local development. “Given that local communities are becoming increasingly active and belligerent against the development of mining projects in Tete and that they are motivated by the protests experienced in Tanzania’s natural gas sector, Exclusive Analysis concludes that Mozambique’s natural gas sector is likely to face similar protests as it develops,” he says.
Besseling tells Mining Weekly that civil protestors sabotaged the construction of liquefied natural gas (LNG) pipelines in Mtwara, which is destined to be the key port for Tanzania’s natural gas sector, in December and January. Damage estimated at $300 000, compounded by about $1-million in overrun costs on the pipeline, was incurred. However, apart from the pipeline attacks, Tanzanian protestors have not been targeting gas companies, as they blame their local government for not enforcing localisation within the growing energy sector, Besseling points out.
He maintains that this lack of local beneficiation has been the primary cause of the stunted development of LNG infrastructure in Mtwara and predicts that the same turn of events is likely to occur in Mozambique. “Although Mozambique, like Tanzania, is redrafting its natural gas legislation, its civil activist groups, political opposition and even some members within the ruling party are already criticising the Mozambique government for the lack of wealth and development in the country, ” Besseling says.
He further maintains that neither the political opposition within Mozambique nor the civil activist groups are having any effect on the natural gas legislation yet. The legislation is drawn up by State-owned companies involved in the petroleum sector and key industry gatekeepers within the natural gas sector who are also involved in the upper echelons of the political system. Besseling predicts, therefore, that those civil society groups “clamouring for change and greater skills development” are more likely to launch protests at construction sites, owing to their lack of legislative influence.
He highlights US-based independent oil and gas exploration and production company Anadarko Petroleum’s LNG development project and that of Italy-based integrated energy company ENI, both based in the Rovuma basin, as potential targets that are likely to face these types of protests as soon as construction begins. Meanwhile, the Mozambique mining sector, which is dominated by mining majors such as Vale, Rio Tinto and the Eurasian Natural Resources Corporation (ENRC), faces ongoing protests.
“The construction of two major railway lines has been disrupted on several occasions in the last 18 months, owing to forced relocations,” explains Besseling. With no way of transporting its coal stock, Brazil-based diversified miner Vale was forced to stockpile. Forced relocation disputes are reportedly resolved for now, which means that production will soon be back on track, but Besseling warns that the unrest will not disappear overnight.
Besides the issue of forced relocations, the lack of local beneficiation, environmental damage and a general public perception that foreign investors are exploiting Mozambique remain problematic. “Vale, Rio Tinto and ENRC, together with other major coal mining players in the country, are likely to have changes made to their contracts over the next few years in terms of local procurement and skills development,” predicts Besseling, adding that changes in taxation and State-ownership policies may also be in the pipeline.
Hundreds Protest Pipeline in Burma’s Rakhine State
Hundreds of residents protested Thursday against a China-backed petroleum pipeline project in western Burma’s Rakhine state over inadequate compensation and demands that the project developer provide better transportation infrastructure and higher salaries for local workers. Around 400 people gathered to protest the Shwe Gas Project in Maday Island off the coast of Kyaukpyu town in the Bay of Bengal, also complaining that the project had polluted rivers which fishermen in the area had depended on for their catch.
“We protested today because we want the world see that the project is not making the lives of local residents better—it has only made things worse,” protester Tun Kyi told RFA’s Burmese Service. The Shwe Gas Project is a joint venture between Beijing’s state-owned China National Petroleum Corporation (CNPC) and Burma’s national petroleum company Myanmar Oil and Gas Enterprise.
A conglomerate of two other companies from Burma, another company from China, two firms from India, and one from South Korea also have a stake in the joint venture South East Asia Gas Pipeline Co, Ltd (SEAGP). Tun Kyi said that residents had received compensation payment for only half of the area expropriated for the project, including a mountain owned by local residents from Maday Island.
But CNPC representatives claimed the company had made the full payment, he said, suggesting that part of the compensation has been unaccounted for. “The Chinese businessmen are treating the local people unfairly. They occupied more than 400 acres [162 hectares] and we received compensation for only about 200 acres [81 hectares],” he said.
“No one knows where the rest of the compensation went. A lot of residents have lost their property.” Protesters also wanted the company to build better transportation infrastructure from the crude oil jetty at Maday Island to the nearby villages of Kyauttan, Ywarma, and Panhteinse, and to supply the area with electricity before continuing with the project. They also called on CNPC to create more job opportunities for local workers and to pay them at international rates.