Signalfire
Documentation on popular resistance, armed struggle and communist politics
Skip to content
  • Home
  • About
  • Analysis & Polemic
  • Armed Struggle & Counter Insurgency
  • Disclaimers
  • Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution
  • International Communist Movement
  • International Maoism and anti-revisionism
  • NABPP-PC and Prison Movement
  • People’s War & Maoism in Nepal
  • People’s War in India
  • People’s War in Peru
  • Siraj Sikder Archive
  • Women Martyrs of the Indian Revolution
← Chinese railroad workers riot in Makkah
The Case For Wiretapping The Internet →

China price for stability raises alarm

Posted on October 14, 2010 by mat

Oct 14

The Chinese government’s bid to maintain stability at all costs is creating a domestic security system so expensive that experts and officials say it is sapping funds needed elsewhere to sustain the country’s economic health.

The ruling Communist Party’s smothering of public support for Nobel Peace Prize winner and jailed dissident, Liu Xiaobo, is the latest example of the lengths, and costs, the authorities are willing to go to keep a lid on even minor events that might seem to threaten its hold on power.

China price for stability raises alarm

China’s total spending on domestic security reached 514 billion yuan (USD 76.7 billion) in 2009, a whisker below the military budget of 532 billion yuan, a group of social researchers from the elite Tsinghua University in Beijing estimated in a report published earlier this year.

“Threats to social stability are constantly being side-stepped and postponed, but that is making social breakdown increasingly grave,” it said. “The current model of stability has reached the point where it cannot continue.”

Nicholas Bequelin, a researcher on China for Human Rights Watch, an international watchdog group called the resources devoted to stability “absolutely humungous”.

“There’s a vicious circle that more security leads to more security,” he said by telephone.

China swaddles all its big meetings, events and sensitive dates with police and guards to scare off trouble-makers, extinguish protests and project power.

The massive security for the 2008 Olympics in Beijing has become a general template, and is on show for preparations for a Party leaders’ meeting in Beijing from Friday.

How much longer?

The show of strength works for now. But many question how much longer it can be effective.

President Hu Jintao and Premier Wen Jiabao will use the Party meeting to hone a five-year economic development plan intended to cement their vows to build a “harmonious society” free of serious division and discontent.

And for the moment, China’s formula of one-party rule and economic growth can ward off serious challenges from below, the public still happy enough with its economic and social gains.

It is later, especially if growth and revenues flag, that worries some Chinese experts and officials.

Firm control of discontent has been a defining policy of China’s government, especially since the pro-democracy protests of 1989 that ended in a bloody crackdown and Party patriarch Deng Xiaoping’s demand that “stability comes before all else.”

Stuck to by successive leaders, that slogan has created an expensive illusion of solid order for which the country may one day pay heavily, the experts and officials said.

“This unyielding stability has already reached the point where it cannot be sustained, because it exacts a huge cost,” Yu Jianrong, a prominent expert on social unrest at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, said in a recent lecture in Beijing.

“What may happen in China in the future is that there are more outbreaks of local turmoil,” he said.

Rapid economic growth over the past two decades has rekindled official worries that social flux and inequality could unsettle Party control.

President Hu chaired a meeting in late September that studied the social strains facing the country, state media reported at the time. He warned officials to be ready for a rough patch.

That means more spending on social welfare, healthcare and rural services in its next five-year plan starting from 2011, the official Xinhua news agency said on Wednesday.

Yet the government’s single-minded demand for officials to snuff out symptoms of unrest is skewing resources and attention away from social needs and into playing cop to monitor and detain potential protesters, say officials and experts.

A study of 10 provinces and local governments showed outlays on domestic security rose faster than for schools, hospitals, and welfare, and often ate up a bigger share of budgets, the Social Sciences Weekly, a Shanghai paper, reported in May.

The focus on averting unrest is skewing officials’ priorities, as well as budgets. Points systems are often used to weigh officials’ promotion prospects based on the number of protests in their areas.

Some local governments demand grassroots officials deposit millions of yuan in “guarantees” every year, and money is taken from the fund if there are protests under their watch, a Chinese magazine, People’s Tribune, reported last month.

“Many local government departments don’t put themselves in the shoes of people in hardship and try to solve the fundamental problems at their root,” Feng Qingyu, a professor at the Chinese Academy of Administration, which trains rising government officials, wrote in a study published in April.

Rather, they worry about “how to increase and maintain security camera systems, how to increase uniformed police and plain clothes security staff”, wrote Feng

This entry was posted in resistance, state security and tagged china, counter insurgency, low intensity conflict, repression, social tension, technocratic social control. Bookmark the permalink.
← Chinese railroad workers riot in Makkah
The Case For Wiretapping The Internet →
  • Anti-Imperialist Organizations

    • ABCF
    • Addameer
    • Arab Red Aid
    • Bayan-USA
    • CCRSRI
    • CGAGPI
    • DSU-JNU
    • Free Georges Ibrahim Abdallah
    • Free Saadat
    • Frente Independente Popular – RJ
    • ICAWPI
    • ICSPWI – Italy
    • India Solidarity-Germany
    • India Solidarity-Sweden
    • INTERNATIONAL COMMITTEE TO SUPPORT THE PEOPLE'S WAR IN INDIA
    • International League of Peoples' Struggle
    • International Red Aid
    • Irish Republican Socialist Party
    • Jericho Movement
    • MLKP
    • Network Free All Political Prisoners
    • Parti Communiste du Bénin
    • Party of Labor-Serbia
    • PCRV
    • PFLP
    • Political Prisoners in Peru
    • Prisoner Info
    • Red Action-Croatia
    • Red Aid Switzerland
    • Revolutionary Construction-Switzerland
    • Revolutionary Cultural Front
    • Revolutionary Democratic Front
    • Revolutionary Unity
    • Secours Rouge Belgium
    • SRI
  • Maoist Organizations

    • All India Federation of Labour Unions
    • Análisis y Opinión
    • Andolonpotrika
    • Antigeitonies
    • ATIK
    • Bündnis gegen imperialististische Aggression
    • CARC
    • Cause du Peuple
    • Confederation for Democratic Rights in Europe
    • Democratic Women's Movement
    • El Pueblo
    • Escuela Política Luis Emilio Recabarren
    • FDLP
    • FER Chile
    • Free Margot Liendo
    • Free Osman Morote
    • Gran Marcha Hacia el Comunismo
    • Halkin Gunlugu
    • Initiative RCP (Austria)
    • Kommunistiska Arbetarkommunen
    • Liga dos Camponeses Pobres
    • Liga Operária
    • Maoist Bolshevik Reorganization Movement
    • Maoist Communist Group
    • Maoist Revolutionary League
    • Maoist Road
    • MER-RSM
    • MOVADEF
    • Movimento Estudantil Popular Revolucionário
    • Movimento Feminino Popular
    • Movimento Femminista Proletario Rivoluzionario
    • National Democratic Front of the Philippines
    • New Democratic Women
    • New Democratic Youth
    • Nova Democracia
    • OCFR
    • OCML-VP
    • Organización Maoísta Para la Reconstitución del Partido Comunista de Colombia
    • Partizan
    • Philippine Revolution Web Central
    • Proletarische Revolution Austria
    • Revolutionary Initiative
    • Revolutionary Internationalist Movement
    • Rot Front Kollektiv
    • Servir le Peuple
    • SOL Germany
    • The Next Front
    • Tjen folket
    • UNIÓN OBRERA COMUNISTA (Mlm)
    • Verein der Neuen Demokratie
  • Maoist Parties

    • Communist (Maoist) Party of Afghanistan
    • Communist Party of Bhutan (Marxist-Leninist-Maoist)
    • Communist Party of Ecuador-Red Sun
    • CPI (Maoist)
    • KKE ML
    • Maoist Communist Party of France
    • Maoist Communist Party of Italy
    • Maoist Communist Party/Turkey-North Kurdistan
    • MCP Manipur
    • Purba Bangla Sarbahara Party-Central Committee
    • RCP Canada
    • TKP/ML
  • Resources

    • Africa in Struggle
    • African Activist Archive Project
    • ANF News
    • Archiv Schwarzer Stern
    • Arm the Spirit Archive
    • Bianet-English
    • Bombard the Headquarters!
    • Camarades
    • CEDEMA
    • Cellules Communistes Combattantes
    • China Labor Bulletin
    • Chuang
    • Communist Working Group Archive
    • Corrispondenza Internazionale
    • CPI (Maoist) Information Bulletin
    • CSPP
    • Daily Cultural Revolution
    • Dazibao Rojo
    • DEM VOLKE DIENEN
    • Dialectical Materialism in China
    • Documents of GP
    • Documents of UFCML
    • Đã Thành Đồ Sơn
    • Early American Marxism
    • El Topo Blindado
    • EROL
    • Farmland Grab
    • Freedom Archives
    • Freilassung
    • Frontier Weekly
    • German Left Poster Archive
    • GPCR Archive
    • IISH Red Army Faction Archive
    • Insurrection News
    • International Red News
    • IRISH REPUBLICAN MARXIST HISTORY PROJECT
    • Israeli Left Archive
    • Isyandan
    • Jinha News
    • L’Internationale
    • Left Russia
    • Liberation Magazine 1967-72
    • MAO Projekt
    • Mao Selected Works
    • Marx to Mao
    • MG documentation
    • ML Translations
    • MLM Mayhem!
    • MLM RSG
    • Naxalbari Magazine
    • New Turkey
    • Other Aspect
    • Palestine Poster Project Archive
    • Paschim Banga Khet Majoor Samity
    • Peking Review
    • Peoples March
    • Peoples Truth
    • PFOC Archive
    • Red News-Lal Shongbad
    • Remembering Lorena Barros
    • Research Unit for Political Economy
    • Resistance & Repression in Greece
    • Revolutionary Democracy
    • Revolutionary Literature Archive
    • Revolutionary Struggle in Italy Archive
    • Rojava Report
    • Ruinas Digitales
    • Samidoun
    • Sanhati
    • SDS Archives
    • sebben he siamo donne
    • Servir ao Povo de Todo Coração
    • Sınıf Teorisi
    • Textos y Documentos del PCP
    • The Workers Dreadnought
    • Throw Out Your Books
    • Turkey Harvest
    • Western Ghats War Front
    • Women Against Sexual Violence and State Repression
    • Works of Charu Mazumdar
    • Works of Siraj Sikder
  • Categories

    • agricultures
    • capital and class
    • conflict within the movement
    • ecological crisis
    • Editor's desk
    • fascist attacks
    • Maoists India
    • news
    • opinion
    • patriarchy
    • prisons
    • privacy
    • resistance
    • state control
    • state security
    • strategy and tactics
    • technology
    • Uncategorized
    • war
    • war on drugs
    • Women Martyrs of The Indian Revolution
  • Recent Posts

    • Letter from your Editor
    • People’s War in India Clippings 11/8/2016
    • Passing of communist activist and union militant Himadri Sen Roy
    • People’s War in India Clippings 8/8/2016
    • People’s War in India Clippings 1/8/2016
    • Brief History of the Armed Communist Formations (FCA)
    • Boycott (World) Social Forum, a Safety Valve for Imperialism
    • ‘Give us Eylem Ataş’s body’
    • People’s War in India Clippings 30/7/2016
    • People’s War in India Clippings 29/7/2016
    • Indian Democracy Unmasked: BJP-RSS and the politics of Communal Hatred-CAFAU
    • Brief history of the Revolutionary Communist Commitee (CoCoRi)
    • People’s War in India Clippings 26/7/2016
    • 12 detained in house raids in Dersim
    • People’s War in India Clippings 24/7/2016
    • People’s War in India Clippings 22/7/2016
    • HBDH: 11 riot police killed in Trabzon
    • Armed wing of Maoist Communist Party eliminates reactionary solder
    • Responsibility claim for the execution of mafioso Habibi in June , Exarhia area – Athens , Greece
    • About the attempted military coup in Turkey KKE (ml)
  • Tags

    • anarchists
    • armed struggle
    • austerity
    • bangladesh
    • chile
    • china
    • counter insurgency
    • ecocide
    • egypt
    • energy
    • france
    • greece
    • history
    • immigration
    • india
    • indonesia
    • international communist movement
    • italy
    • just another police murder
    • kurdistan
    • land tenure
    • low intensity conflict
    • manipur
    • maoism
    • maoist
    • naxal
    • nepal
    • nigeria
    • pakistan
    • palestine
    • peru
    • philippines
    • radical right
    • repression
    • revisionism
    • riot
    • social tension
    • south africa
    • state terror
    • strike
    • tunisia
    • turkey
    • united kingdom
    • united states
    • worker resistance
  • Archives

Signalfire
Proudly powered by WordPress.